A toilet that keeps running is usually an easy fix…jiggle the handle and 9 times out of 10, the plunger reseats, the tank fills up, and you don’t have to think about it again.  Beyond that, we find that most of our customers get pretty anxious when facing toilet related problems. While some issues are equally as easy to repair, others are a sign it may be time to replace your toilet before more costly repairs or even property damage can occur.

At Ben Franklin Plumbing, we help customers on a budget troubleshoot toilet problems every day. However, customer education about basic home plumbing systems is also our goal, so let’s walk through some common factors to consider when it comes to repairing or replacing your toilet and the advantages/disadvantages of each.

1) Assess the Problem

Before any decision, you have to know what you’re dealing with! Common toilet problems include:

  • Running Toilet:  We’ve already mentioned this one, but sometimes a handle jiggle won’t do it, so we’ll dive into this a bit more below.

  • Leaks: Water pooling around the base or a constant trickle into the bowl can signal a leak.

  • Weak Flush: Insufficient flushing power can lead to frequent clogs and frustration.

  • Cracks: Visible cracks in the tank or bowl can lead to leaks and structural issues.

  • Aging: Older toilets might not function efficiently, leading to higher water bills and frequent repairs.

2) When to REPAIR

Here are some scenarios where repair is the best option:

  1. Minor Leaks: If the leak is due to a worn-out flapper, valve, or seal, a simple replacement part can often fix the issue.

  2. Running Toilet: This is usually caused by a faulty fill valve, flapper, or float. These parts are relatively inexpensive and easy to replace.

  3. Weak Flush: Cleaning the rim holes and siphon jet can improve the flushing power. Replacing the fill valve and flapper can also help. (If the words “rim holes” and “siphon jets” already have you saying “no thanks!” to the DIY approach, your local Ben Franklin Plumbing professional is standing by to help!)

  4. Loose Parts: Tightening bolts and screws or replacing a wax seal can resolve issues with a wobbly toilet.

Advantages of Repair:

  • Cost-Effective: Repairs are usually cheaper than replacing the entire toilet.

  • Quick Fix: Many repairs can be completed within an hour or two.

  • Less Disruption: Repairing a toilet typically involves minimal disruption to your bathroom.

Disadvantages of Repair:

  • Temporary Solution: Depending on the age and condition of your toilet, repairs might only offer a temporary fix.

  • Frequent Repairs: Older toilets might require frequent repairs, leading to increased costs over time.

3) When to REPAIR

Consider replacing your toilet if:

  1. Cracks: Visible cracks in the tank or bowl can lead to leaks and pose a safety risk.

  2. Frequent Repairs: If you find yourself repeatedly fixing the same issues, it might be more cost-effective to invest in a new toilet.

  3. Inefficiency: Older toilets can use up to 3.5 gallons per flush, whereas newer models use as little as 1.28 gallons, according to the EPA. Upgrading to a more efficient toilet can save money on your water bill.

  4. Outdated Design: If your toilet is decades old, it might not match the aesthetics of a modern bathroom. A new toilet can enhance the look of your bathroom (especially valuable if you are about to put your house on the market).

  5. Age of the Toilet: This goes hand-in-hand with #4, if your toilet’s external look isn’t necessarily outdated, its internal components could be. If it’s more than 10-15 years old, replacement might be a better investment due to the improved efficiency and technology of modern toilets.

  6. Severe Damage: If the toilet has significant damage beyond basic wear and tear, replacement is often the best option.

Advantages of Replacement:

  • Efficiency: Newer models are designed to use less water, which can significantly reduce water bills.

  • Reliability: A new toilet is less likely to require repairs, providing peace of mind.

  • Modern Features: Contemporary toilets come with features such as dual flush options, comfortable height, and improved flushing mechanisms.

  • Aesthetic Appeal: Replacing an old toilet can refresh the look of your bathroom.

Disadvantages of Replacement:

  • Higher Upfront Cost: Purchasing a new toilet and hiring a plumber for installation can be more expensive than repairs.

  • Time-Consuming: Replacing a toilet involves more time and effort compared to simple repairs.

  • Disposal: The old toilet needs to be disposed of properly and depending on who you call, this could involve additional costs. This is another reason we hope you’ll allow Ben Franklin Plumbing to assist with all your plumbing needs, we are well-versed in how to properly and affordably dispose of your old toilet.

Does toilet troubleshooting and repair seem too daunting? Rest assured the insured and skilled professionals at Ben Franklin Plumbing address your toilet concerns correctly, safely, and affordably the first time. Plus, our friendly technicians arrive with fully-stocked trucks so they can address your plumbing issue on the spot without making you wait for new parts to be shipped, etc. 

If you put “Best Plumbers Near Me” in your search engine, we’re at the top of that list, now let us be at the top of yours! Be it an emergency or routine plumbing service, we’ll respond quickly, quote fairly, and talk to you honestly. Our monthly service and product specials can save you money.

Schedule a service call today. If we end up doing a repair, we’ll waive the service fee!

Visit http://www.benfranklinplumbing.com or call our 24/7 customer service line today 800.471.0809.